16 baby dummies for soothing and settling

Posted in All, Babies, Buying for Baby and tagged .

Best baby dummies for soothing and settling | Mum's Grapevine

Listen for a second mum, that’s the sweet sound of silence. Baby dummies are a godsend for soothing little ones, one suck at a time.

A baby dummy is a rubber, silicone or plastic nipple substitute that an infant suckles on to help them settle. Also known as soothers or pacifiers, they are capable of triggering a baby’s innate calming reflex. Available in almost every colour under the sun, bub can be coordinated as well as content.

To help you find your go-to dummy, we’ve chewed over many options to bring you the best brands available in Australia.

Types of dummies for babies

Natural Rubber Soother

Cherry-shaped dummies are the most popular choice when it comes to choosing a soother. With a round top, they’re similar in shape to many traditional bottle teats.

Orthodontic baby dummies are ergonomically shaped pacifiers designed to facilitate healthy dental development. They are usually round on one side and flat on the other.

Symmetrical dummies are often recommended for breastfed babies as they’re similar in shape to mum’s nipples. They usually have a smaller top than cherry-shaped styles and always sit correctly in the mouth.

16 baby dummies for soothing and settling

Check out our handy list of top brands to keep little mouths moving – and your heart rate down.

In no particular order, here are 16 baby dummies for infants:


BIBS baby pacifiers Australia

BIBS Pacifiers (from $9.95)

Calm bub, in colour! Made ethically in Denmark from 100% food-safe materials, choose from a range of styles to suit every baby. Our pick is the BIBS De Lux Glow which features a cleverly designed nipple that mimics breastfeeding – and even glows in the dark.

Bumi Bebe

Bumi Bebe Natural Rubber Pacifiers

Bumi Bebe Natural Rubber Pacifiers ($24.95)

Cute as a button (and we don’t just mean bub), these planet-friendly pacifiers are made of 100% natural rubber. Featuring a round nipple, they’re soft and gentle on bub’s face and contain no nasties. We’re also digging the retro vibes and cotton candy shades.


Chicco Baby Soothers

Chicco Baby Physio Soft Soothers ($14.95)

With science behind it, the Physio Soft Soother helps promote the correct development of your little one’s palate. The grooved and angled shape encourages the uniform distribution of tongue pressure and the super-thin base ensures proper mouth closure.

Free shipping with Amazon Prime – get a free 30-day trial here.

Dr Browns

Dr Browns PreVent Soothers Glow-in-the-Dark

Dr Browns PreVent Soothers Glow-in-the-dark ($15.95)

It’s a high five to low-pressure comfort and a design that helps prevent dental conditions like crossbite. Developed by a paediatric dentist, the BPA-free, soft, suction-release bulb spreads wider as they suck and the air channel reduces suction. It also illuminates at night.

Natural Rubber Soothers

Natural Rubber Soothers

Natural Rubber Soothers With Reusable Case (from $10)

Here’s a great all-rounder and we’re not just talking about the shape. This single-piece 100% sustainable rubber soother is hygienic, free from all nasties and aids breastfeeding. Choose from eco paper packaging or reusable cases.

Tommee Tippee

Tommee Tippee Advanced Sensitive Baby Dummies

Tommee Tippee Advanced Sensitive Soother (from $12.95)

This phthalate-free soother has an open shield that curves away from bub’s delicate face, and the airflow from the large holes prevents moisture build-up that leads to irritated skin. Easy to clean, the durable silicone teat is symmetrical in shape.

Doddle & Co

Doddle and Co Pop and Go Dummy

Doddle & Co Pop And Go Dummy (from $12.95)

Mummas rejoice, this silicone dummy is a clever 2-in-1 that eliminates the need for a case – just pinch to tuck the nipple away. Super stylish and free of nasties, the nipple easily withstands teething gnaws. Simply pop into the dishwasher to clean.


Hevea Orthodontic Baby Soother

Hevea Natural Orthodontic Rubber Soother ($17.95)

Hevea’s timeless style is carried on one suck at a time with this orthodontic design. It’s made from a solid piece of hygienic 100% natural and biodegradable rubber and features star and moon shapes that provide ventilation and vacuum around the mouth. Clever.


Haakaa Silicone Baby Dummy

Haakaa Silicone Dummy ($16)

Lovingly designed to mimic the shape of mumma’s breast, this soft, 100% silicone dummy is an all-rounder. Its u-shaped design promotes natural breathing through the nose, and if there’s a cranky teether on your hands, it can be popped into the freezer to bring relief.


NUK Baby Soothers

NUK Baby Soothers ($11.95)

The sweet design is cute, but the benefits are what you’ll appreciate. The asymmetrical shape on all NUK soothers is designed to promote an optimal interplay between the lips, palate, jaw and tongue. This two-pack also comes with a reusable sterilising case.

Free shipping with Amazon Prime – get a free 30-day trial here.


Philips Avent Soothies for Babies

Phillips Avent Soothies ($15.95)

The unique shape of these ‘beary’ cute dummies means you can put your finger in the nipple to help them suckle. Made of BPA-free medical-grade silicone, the collapsible nipple has a symmetrical shape that respects your baby’s palate, teeth and gums as they grow.

Free shipping with Amazon Prime – get a free 30-day trial here.


Frigg Classic Baby Dummies

Frigg Classic Dummies ($19.95)

The clean lines of these Denmark-made dummies aren’t just aesthetic. The outward curve helps keep the pacifier off bub’s delicate skin, preventing irritation. Free from BPA, PVC and Phthalates, they’re available in a range of ultra-gorgeous hue combinations.


Nanobebe Flexy Pacifiers

Nanobebe Flexy Pacifiers ($12.99)

Bend and flex! Lightweight and ergonomically designed, this 100% silicone one-piece pacifier flexes to stay in baby’s mouth. It’s contoured to comfortably frame their face and the extra soft nipple reminds them of mum.

Free shipping with Amazon Prime – get a free 30-day trial here.


Jollypop Newborn Dummies

Jollypop Newborn Dummies ($14.95)

It’s soft, flexible and the preferred dummy used in hospitals across Australia for 0-3-month-olds. With a curved shape and no hard inner guard, the silicone Jollypop is super comfortable for bub. You’ll love the easy-to-hold loop handle with nubs for extra grip.

Sophie La Girafe

Sophie La Giraffe Natural Rubber Pacifier

Sophie La Girafe Natural Rubber Pacifier ($18.91)

It’s Sophie La Girafe to the rescue again, this time to soothe and settle. Made from one solid piece of 100% rubber, it has holes for ventilation giving extra comfort. Ergonomically designed to adapt to bub’s face, there are two age ranges to choose from.

Free shipping with Amazon Prime – get a free 30-day trial here.


Fred Novelty Moustache Baby Dummy

Fred Chill, Baby Novelty Moustache Pacifier ($14.95)

Combine a moving mouth with a moustache and giggles are on the cards. Light-hearted parents will enjoy photo opportunities with their little man either awake or asleep. Designed for 0-6 months, it’s made with non-toxic plastic and food-grade silicone.

Are dummies safe?

Absolutely, but certain precautions are advised. These include choosing a one-piece model that can’t break apart and become a choking hazard and being aware of the age recommendation and maximum length of use on the label before giving it to your baby. To prevent loose parts, regularly check for worn or degraded nipples.

When can I introduce a dummy?

Bottle-fed babies can use pacifiers from birth. If you’re breastfeeding, wait 4-6 weeks in order to establish a good nursing routine. However, studies have shown that unrestricted dummy use in healthy, full-term infants has no impact on the continuation of breastfeeding.

How should I clean a pacifier?

Sterilise dummies for babies under six months. Babies over six months are more resistant to infections and you will only need to wash the dummy in soap and water.

This article is curated by our Editors and includes affiliates and/or paid inclusions. See our Disclosure Policy.

16 baby dummies for soothing and settling | Mum's Grapevine

Know a pacifier we should add to our list? Contact us and let us know.

Read these roundups next …

If you’re after more helpful products for bub, you’re in the right spot. From swaddles to cloth nappies, our lists include Australia’s most coveted brands and stores.

Read this: The clever way to stop baby losing the dummy at night


Continue your search for the best dummies

Looking for the best soothers and still not sure if any of these are right for you? Join one of the Mum’s Grapevine Facebook Baby Groups and ask thousands of other mums what they recommend. They are grouped together by birth date so everyone is going through the same stages at the same time.

Click here >> Mum’s Grapevine Facebook Groups << and find your group today!

Share On